JLPT N5ComparisonUpdated

ある vs いる aru · iru

いる is the usual existence verb for people and animals; ある is usual for objects, plants, and events. 猫がいる means “there is a cat,” while 本がある means “there is a book.” Both also appear in possession expressions. The distinction is a useful default about the way a referent is treated in context, with figurative, historical, and dialectal exceptions.

also written aru / iru / あります / います

いる — for things that move under their own will · ある — for everything else, vehicles included · both also mean 'to have'

Sentences

6 sentences, word by word

いる — an animal in the park

polite

。

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

公園

こうえん [0]

park

noun · the place something is located

Ask Rikai

に

に

to; at; into

particle · a point something reaches — a place, a time, a person, or a state

Ask Rikai

猫

ねこ [1]

cat

noun · an animal, so it moves under its own will

Ask Rikai

が

が

marks the subject

particle · what the sentence is about — with 好き, 分かる and potentials, the object

Ask Rikai

います

います

there is (animate)

polite いる · chosen because a cat decides where it goes

いるN5exists · animate

Ask Rikai

There's a cat in the park.

ある — an object on the desk

polite

。

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

机

つくえ [0]

desk

noun · a writing desk, not a dining table

Ask Rikai

の

の

links noun to noun

particle · A の B = B belonging to A

Ask Rikai

上

うえ [0]

on top of

noun of position · 机の上 is 'the top of the desk'

Ask Rikai

に

に

to; at; into

particle · a point something reaches — a place, a time, a person, or a state

Ask Rikai

本

ほん [1]

book

noun · an inanimate object

Ask Rikai

が

が

marks the subject

particle · what the sentence is about — with 好き, 分かる and potentials, the object

Ask Rikai

あります

あります

there is (inanimate)

polite ある · nothing here moves of its own accord

あるN5exists · inanimate

Ask Rikai

There's a book on the desk.

ある — the vehicle case

plain

。

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

駅

えき [1]

station

noun · the location being described

Ask Rikai

の

の

links noun to noun

particle · A の B = B belonging to A

Ask Rikai

前

まえ [1]

in front of

noun of position · the space outside the entrance

Ask Rikai

に

に

to; at; into

particle · a point something reaches — a place, a time, a person, or a state

Ask Rikai

タクシー

タクシー [1]

taxi

noun · a vehicle, so it takes ある despite moving

あるN5exists · vehicles too

Ask Rikai

が

が

marks the subject

particle · what the sentence is about — with 好き, 分かる and potentials, the object

Ask Rikai

ある

ある

there is

plain ある · here closer to 'there's one available'

Ask Rikai

There's a taxi outside the station.

ある — an event on the calendar

polite

。

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

明日

あした [3]

tomorrow

noun used adverbially · relative time, no particle

Ask Rikai

会議

かいぎ [1]

meeting

noun · an event rather than a thing or a person

Ask Rikai

が

が

marks the subject

particle · what the sentence is about — with 好き, 分かる and potentials, the object

Ask Rikai

あります

あります

there is; it's scheduled

polite ある · events exist on a calendar, so ある

あるN5exists · events

Ask Rikai

There's a meeting tomorrow.

いる — possession, for people

polite

。

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

日本語

にほんご [0]

Japanese (the language)

noun · 日 sun + 本 origin + 語 language

Ask Rikai

が

が

marks the subject

particle · what the sentence is about — with 好き, 分かる and potentials, the object

Ask Rikai

話せる

はなせる [3]

can speak

potential of 話す · the object takes が, not を

Ask Rikai

友達

ともだち [0]

friend

noun · a person, so possession uses いる

Ask Rikai

が

が

marks the subject

particle · what the sentence is about — with 好き, 分かる and potentials, the object

Ask Rikai

います

います

I have

polite いる · possession of a person, still marked が

いるN5to have · people

Ask Rikai

I have a friend who speaks Japanese.

ない — the irregular negative

plain

。

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

今

いま [1]

now

noun used adverbially · the present moment

Ask Rikai

は

は

as for — the topic

particle · written は, read わ

Ask Rikai

お金

おかね [0]

money

noun · the お is fixed in this word

Ask Rikai

が

が

marks the subject

particle · what the sentence is about — with 好き, 分かる and potentials, the object

Ask Rikai

ない

ない

there isn't; I don't have

plain negative of ある · irregular, and it inflects as an い-adjective

ないN5the negative of ある

Ask Rikai

I don't have any money right now.

Structure

Where does each verb go?

公園に猫が いる

公園に猫がいます. People and animals. Existence takes に, not で — nothing is happening, something simply is. Events are the exception; see below.

机の上に本が ある

机の上に本があります. Objects, plants, buildings. Same frame, different verb.

会議 / 試験 / 約束+がある

明日会議があります. Events take ある even though they involve people — an appointment is not a creature. Their location takes で, not に: 大阪で会議があります, because a meeting is something that takes place.

ある → ない·いる → いない

ある has no あらない. Its plain negative is ない, which is also the adjective 'nonexistent' — that is why it inflects like one.

Meaning

The line that actually holds

A useful default is whether the referent is treated as animate. いる normally covers people and animals. Objects, plants, and events usually take ある — including plants, which are alive but usually treated as stationary referents.

Vehicles are the case that breaks the textbook rule. タクシーがある, バスがある — a taxi moves, but nothing about it is volitional, so it patterns with objects. What you are usually saying with these is that one is available.

Both verbs also mean “to have”. お金がある is I have money; 友達がいる is I have a friend. The thing owned takes が rather than を, because grammatically nothing is being acted on — something merely exists, described from the owner's side.

Events take ある. 明日会議があります. A meeting is full of people and is still not a creature; what exists is the appointment. The same goes for 試験, 約束 and 時間.

One old usage you will meet in reading. 子供がある for “to have children” is attested and now sounds dated or formal; modern speech uses 子供がいる. Worth recognising rather than producing; it shows that the usual people-versus-things pattern has historical exceptions.

Watch out

Where ある and いる go wrong

Treating the rule as living vs non-living

Plants are alive and take ある; taxis are not and take ある too. The test that works is whether the thing moves because it chose to.

Reaching for あらない

There is no such form. The plain negative of ある is ない, and it conjugates like an い-adjective: なかった, なくて.

Using を for “have”

お金をある does not work. Both verbs take が for the thing possessed, because grammatically it is existing, not being acted on.

Also asked

Questions people ask about ある and いる

Is it really animate vs inanimate?

Close enough to get you started, and it breaks on two fronts. Plants are animate and take ある; vehicles are inanimate, move, and also take ある. The better test is self-propelled will.

Why does a taxi take ある?

Because nothing about a taxi is volitional — it moves, but it does not decide to. タクシーがある is also usually about availability: there's one to be had.

How do I say “I have”?

お金がある for things, 友達がいる for people. The animacy split carries over, and what you have is marked が.

ある or 持っている for possession?

持っている suggests physically holding or owning a concrete item — 傘を持っている. ある is broader and covers time, money and opportunities, which you cannot hold.

Why is the negative ない and not あらない?

ある is irregular in the negative, and the result is not a verb at all — ない behaves as an い-adjective, which is why you get なかった rather than あらなかった.

What about 子供がある?

It is real, it means “to have children,” and it now reads as dated or formal. Modern speech uses 子供がいる. Recognise it in reading rather than producing it.

References

Sources and usage notes

Japan Foundation: Prescriptive and descriptive grammar — Discusses historical and contemporary variation in いる/ある, opposing an absolute animacy or will rule.

Nearby

Points that live next door

One email on launch day

That's the whole list. rikAI is an iPhone app and it isn't out yet.