JLPT N1ComparisonUpdated

べからず vs まじき vs てはならない bekarazu · majiki · te wa naranai

べからず is an old-style prohibition, まじき means unbecoming, and てはならない means must not. 立ち入るべからず forbids entry in an archaic style. 教師にあるまじき行為 judges conduct against a role. てはならない is a direct formal prohibition used in rules; everyday speech often uses てはいけない instead.

also written bekarazu / majiki / tewa naranai / 立入禁止

べからず — the sign on the fence · まじき — unbecoming of someone in that position · てはならない — the ordinary written prohibition

Sentences

6 sentences, word by word

べからず — the sign on the fence

plain

。

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

立入る

たちいる [0]

enter; set foot in

godan verb · dictionary form, and the 送り仮名 is often dropped on signs

Ask Rikai

べからず

べからず

do not

classical negative of べし · survives mainly on signage

べからずN1do not · classical

Ask Rikai

No entry.

べからざる — the attributive form

plain

。

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

それ

それ

that

pronoun · the act under discussion

Ask Rikai

は

は

as for — the topic

particle · written は, read わ

Ask Rikai

許す

ゆるす [2]

forgive; permit

godan verb · dictionary form before べからざる

Ask Rikai

べからざる

べからざる

that must not be

attributive べからず · the form that modifies a noun

べからざるN1that must not be · attributive

Ask Rikai

行為

こうい [1]

act; conduct

noun · formal; 行動 is behaviour more broadly

Ask Rikai

だった

だった

was

plain past copula · closing the verdict

Ask Rikai

It was an unforgivable act.

まじき — measured against a role

plain

。

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

それ

それ

that

pronoun · the act being judged

Ask Rikai

は

は

as for — the topic

particle · written は, read わ

Ask Rikai

教師

きょうし [1]

teacher

noun · the role the act is measured against — まじき requires one

Ask Rikai

に

に

for; of

particle · part of 〜にあるまじき — it names the role, not a destination

Ask Rikai

あるまじき

あるまじき

unbecoming of

classical · 〜にあるまじき, the only shape まじき really appears in

にあるまじきN1unbecoming of

Ask Rikai

行為

こうい [1]

conduct

noun · what まじき almost always modifies

Ask Rikai

だ

だ

is

plain copula · the verdict stated flatly

Ask Rikai

That is conduct unbecoming of a teacher.

てはならない — the written rule

plain

。

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

この

この

this

demonstrative · the experience just referred to

Ask Rikai

経験

けいけん [0]

experience

noun · 経験する to experience something

Ask Rikai

を

を

marks the direct object

particle · pronounced お

Ask Rikai

忘れて

わすれて

forget

て-form of 忘れる · what はならない attaches to

Ask Rikai

は

は

(part of てはならない)

particle · the は of the prohibition frame, not a topic marker

Ask Rikai

ならない

ならない

must not

negative of なる · the written prohibition, neutral in tone

てはならないN1must not · written

Ask Rikai

You must never forget this experience.

てはいけません — said to a person

polite

。

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

芝生

しばふ [0]

grass; lawn

noun · a planted lawn, not 草 growing wild

Ask Rikai

に

に

to; at; into

particle · a point something reaches — a place, a time, a person, or a state

Ask Rikai

入って

はいって

go onto

て-form of 入る · 芝生に入る, to step onto the lawn

Ask Rikai

は

は

(part of てはいけない)

particle · same frame は as てはならない above

Ask Rikai

いけません

いけません

must not

polite negative potential of いく · what a person says to a person

てはいけないN4must not · spoken

Ask Rikai

You mustn't walk on the grass.

べからず — the proverb

plain

。

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

初心

しょしん [0]

one's original intention

noun · the beginner's resolve you had at the start

Ask Rikai

忘る

わする [2]

forget

classical form of 忘れる · preserved inside the proverb

Ask Rikai

べからず

べからず

must not

classical negative · this proverb is where most people meet it

べからずN1must not · classical

Ask Rikai

Never forget where you started.

Structure

How each one is built

入る / 忘る+べからず

立入るべからず. する becomes すべからず. The attributive form べからざる modifies a noun: 許すべからざる行為.

教師 / 学生に+あるまじき+行為 / 発言

教師にあるまじき行為. The role is compulsory — the whole point is measuring the act against what that position demands.

忘れ / 入っ+てはならない

忘れてはならない. Productive with any verb, and the register of a written rule rather than a sign.

Verb [て]+はいけない

入ってはいけません. What a person says to another person. The three above are for signs, judgements and documents.

Meaning

A sign, a judgement, and a rule

べからず is classical, and you will mostly read it. 立入るべからず on a fence, 初心忘るべからず as a proverb. It is the negative of the old べし, and producing it in ordinary prose sounds like costume drama.

まじき needs a role to measure against. 教師にあるまじき行為 — conduct unbecoming of a teacher. The condemnation is not that the act was bad in general, but that someone in that position did it.

てはならない is the workaday written prohibition. Contracts, safety notices, school rules. It carries no archaism and no judgement about character — it simply forbids.

てはならない is productive for direct prohibition. It attaches to verbs in formal rules. べからず is mostly seen in set or stylized writing, while まじき often occurs as 〜にあるまじき before a noun.

The spoken form is てはいけない. Said to a person, even てはならない is stiff — a sign says ならない, a teacher says いけません, and a friend says だめ.

Watch out

Where these three go wrong

まじき without a role

The pattern measures an act against a position, so it needs one: 教師にあるまじき, 学生にあるまじき. On its own it has nothing to compare against.

Using べからず in ordinary writing

It reads as archaic. An email or a report wants てはならない; べからず belongs on a sign or inside a proverb.

てはならない spoken to someone

It is the register of a document. To a person, てはいけません — or だめ between friends.

Also asked

Questions people ask about these three

Which one would I actually use?

てはならない if you are writing a rule, and てはいけません if you are speaking to someone. The other two are for recognition.

Why does まじき need a role in front?

Because the judgement is comparative — the act is unbecoming of someone in that position. Without the role there is no standard to fall short of.

What is べからざる?

The attributive form, used before a noun: 許すべからざる行為. べからず ends a sentence; べからざる modifies.

How does する behave with べからず?

It becomes すべからず, from the classical す. The same irregularity gives you すべき in the positive.

Is 初心忘るべからず everyday Japanese?

The proverb is, and the grammar inside it is not. People quote it whole, much as an English speaker quotes a line of Shakespeare without adopting the syntax.

てはならない or てはいけない?

ならない leans written and impersonal — signs, rules, contracts. いけない leans spoken and situational. It is a tendency, and both are understood everywhere.

References

Sources and usage notes

Nihon Kokugo Daijiten: まじ — Documents the classical auxiliary and its attributive form まじき, including prohibitive senses.

Nearby

Points that live next door

One email on launch day

That's the whole list. rikAI is an iPhone app and it isn't out yet.