JLPT N4ComparisonUpdated

てもいい vs なければならない te mo ii · nakereba naranai

〜てもいい permits; 〜てはいけない prohibits; 〜なければならない requires; 〜なくてもいい says something is unnecessary. 行ってもいい means “you may go,” and 行かなくてもいい means “you need not go.” 行かなければならない means “you must go,” while 行ってはいけない means “you must not go.” Casual speech often shortens obligation forms to 行かなきゃ or 行かないと.

also written temoii / nakereba naranai / てはいけない / なくてもいい / なきゃ / ないと

てもいい — you may · てはいけない — you must not · なければならない — you must; なくてもいい — you need not

Sentences

6 sentences, word by word

てもいいですか — asking permission

polite

?

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

写真

しゃしん [0]

photograph

noun · 写真を撮る is the set phrase

Ask Rikai

を

を

marks the direct object

particle · pronounced お

Ask Rikai

撮って

とって

take

て-form of 撮る · 撮る for photos, not 取る

Ask Rikai

も

も

too; as well

particle · replaces を and が, never stacks with them

Ask Rikai

いい

いい

is fine

い-adjective · 'even if you do, it's good'

てもいいN4may · permission

Ask Rikai

です

です

(polite ending)

copula · politeness on an い-adjective predicate

Ask Rikai

か

か

(question)

particle · which is what makes it a request rather than an offer

Ask Rikai

May I take a photo?

てはいけない — prohibition

polite

。

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

ここ

ここ

here

pronoun · the place near the speaker

Ask Rikai

で

で

in; at — where it happens

particle · where the action happens, or the manner it happens in

Ask Rikai

写真

しゃしん [0]

photograph

noun · the same set phrase, now forbidden

Ask Rikai

を

を

marks the direct object

particle · pronounced お

Ask Rikai

撮って

とって

take

て-form of 撮る · joining to はいけません

Ask Rikai

は

は

as for — the topic

particle · written は, read わ

Ask Rikai

いけません

いけません

won't do; is not allowed

polite negative potential of いく · the prohibition half of the grid

てはいけないN4must not

Ask Rikai

You mustn't take photos here.

なければなりません — obligation

polite

。

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

明日

あした [3]

tomorrow

noun used adverbially · the deadline

Ask Rikai

までに

までに

by (a deadline)

particle · a point by which it must be done

Ask Rikai

宿題

しゅくだい [0]

homework

noun · 宿題を出す, to hand it in

Ask Rikai

を

を

marks the direct object

particle · pronounced お

Ask Rikai

出さなければ

ださなければ

if I don't hand it in

ない-form of 出す minus い, plus ければ · the first negative

Ask Rikai

なりません

なりません

it won't do

polite negative of なる · the second negative, giving obligation

なければならないN4must

Ask Rikai

I have to hand in my homework by tomorrow.

なくてもいい — you don't have to

polite

。

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

靴

くつ [2]

shoes

noun · 靴を脱ぐ is the set phrase

Ask Rikai

を

を

marks the direct object

particle · pronounced お

Ask Rikai

脱がなくて

ぬがなくて

not taking off

ない-form of 脱ぐ minus い, plus くて · the negative て-form

Ask Rikai

も

も

too; as well

particle · replaces を and が, never stacks with them

Ask Rikai

いい

いい

is fine

い-adjective · 'even not doing it is fine' — release, not prohibition

なくてもいいN4need not

Ask Rikai

です

です

(polite ending)

copula · politeness on the い-adjective

Ask Rikai

You don't have to take your shoes off.

なきゃ — the spoken contraction

plain

。

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

もう

もう

already

adverb · marking that the time has come

Ask Rikai

帰らなきゃ

かえらなきゃ

gotta go home

contraction of 帰らなければ · the ending is simply dropped

なきゃN4gotta · spoken

Ask Rikai

I've got to go home already.

ないと — the other spoken option

plain

、。

Hover, tap, or tab through the words.

急がないと

いそがないと

if we don't hurry

ない-form of 急ぐ + と · the consequence is left unsaid

ないとN4have to · spoken

Ask Rikai

遅れる

おくれる [0]

we'll be late

ichidan verb · the consequence, here actually stated

Ask Rikai

よ

よ

you know

sentence particle · pressing the point

Ask Rikai

We have to hurry or we'll be late.

Structure

How the four are built

Verb [て]+もいい

帰ってもいい. As a question — 帰ってもいいですか — it is the standard request for permission.

Verb [て]+はいけない

入ってはいけない. Prohibition. Contracts to 入っちゃだめ in speech, which is softer and much more common between friends.

Verb [ない minus い]+ければならない

行かなければならない. Built on the ない-form, not the て-form — 行かな+ければ. This is where the shape trips people.

Verb [ない minus い]+くてもいい

行かなくてもいい. You don't have to go. Same ない-form base, joined with くても instead.

Meaning

ならない vs いけない vs だめ

The grid. てもいい permits, てはいけない prohibits, なければならない requires, なくてもいい releases. Note that the opposite of “you must” is “you need not,” not “you must not” — the pattern learners most often reach for wrongly.

The obligation forms are double negatives. 行かなければならない is literally “if you do not go, it will not do.” Nothing in it means “must”; the obligation falls out of negating a negative, which is why the shape looks so unlike its meaning.

ならない and いけない lean different ways. ならない tends toward general rules and written Japanese; いけない toward this particular situation and speech. It is a tendency rather than a rule, and in most sentences either is accepted.

Speech contracts all of it. なければ → なきゃ, なくては → なくちゃ, and the ending usually drops off entirely: 行かなきゃ is a complete sentence. Keep the full form for writing.

〜ないと is the third spoken option. 行かないと — the conditional と with the consequence left unsaid. Very common, entirely casual, and the same trick as なきゃ: the threat is implied.

Watch out

Where the four go wrong

Treating てはいけない as the opposite of なければならない

The opposite of “you must” is “you need not” — なくてもいい. てはいけない is the opposite of てもいい. Two axes, not one.

Building the obligation form on the て-form

行ってなければならない is not a thing. The base is the ない-form with its final い removed: 行かな+ければ.

Writing なきゃ or ないと

Both are speech. In an email, an essay, or anything read by a superior, use なければなりません — and note that なきゃ normally drops its ending entirely, which is part of why it reads as casual.

Also asked

Questions people ask about these four

What's the difference between ならない and いけない?

A tendency rather than a rule. ならない leans toward general rules and writing; いけない toward the situation in front of you and speech. In most sentences either is accepted.

Why is “must” a double negative?

行かなければならない is literally “if I don't go, it won't do.” The obligation is the product of two negatives, which is why nothing in the shape looks like “must.”

What's the opposite of なければならない?

なくてもいい, “you don't have to.” Not てはいけない — that is the opposite of てもいい.

How do I ask permission politely?

〜てもいいですか is the everyday form. To go further up, 〜てもよろしいでしょうか, or the humble 〜させていただけますか.

Is なきゃ rude?

Casual rather than rude. It is fine with friends and family and out of place in writing or with a superior, where なければなりません belongs.

What is 〜ちゃだめ?

The spoken contraction of 〜てはだめ, itself a softer 〜てはいけない. 食べちゃだめ — don't eat that. Common to children and between friends.

References

Sources and usage notes

Japan Foundation: Expressing intention — Explains てもいい as an expression of acceptability that can convey permission in context.

Nearby

Points that live next door

One email on launch day

That's the whole list. rikAI is an iPhone app and it isn't out yet.